Substack Polls and Surveys VS FeedLetter - Which Should You Use?
Substack gives you two built-in ways to ask your readers: polls and surveys. FeedLetter is a feedback tool that works with simple links, also on Substack. So which one should you use?
I built FeedLetter, so I am biased. But I’d rather tell you when you don’t need it.
What Substack offers
Polls sit inside a post. You add a question with a few answers, readers vote, and they see how the others voted. Good for quick, fun questions and for engagement.
Surveys live on their own page. You can ask several questions, only your subscribers can answer, and only you see the answers. Good for the big reader survey once or twice a year.
Now a quick decision guide for you.
If you already use Substack polls and are happy …
… then keep using them.
If you only want feedback inside your Substack posts and the polls give you what you need, there is no reason to add another tool. They are free, built in and your readers know them.
If you want feedback on every issue …
… then pick FeedLetter.
A poll is a single question, and it doesn’t tell you why readers voted the way they did. A survey gets you reasons, but people don’t like surveys, and you can’t send one with every issue. In my experience, even the most engaged readers stop answering when you send more than two a year.
FeedLetter sits in between. You add three links to the end of each issue. Readers click one, land on a comment page and can tell you why, by text or with a voice message. It doesn’t look or feel like a survey, and that’s why it works with every issue. Over time, you see which issues and topics work and which don’t.
If you want feedback in other places too …
… then pick FeedLetter.
Substack polls and surveys work on Substack. FeedLetter works anywhere you can place a link or a snippet: in after-sales emails, in ebooks, in online courses and with a feedback widget on your own website.
If you care about vendor independence or privacy …
… then pick FeedLetter too.
Many writers leave Substack at some point for a platform with more control. Your polls and surveys don’t move with you. FeedLetter is just links, so it works the same on every email platform, and the history of your issues stays with you.
And then there’s privacy. Only subscribers can answer a Substack survey. In FeedLetter, nobody has to sign in or subscribe to give you feedback. Readers stay anonymous and add their name or email only if they want to. And readers who feel safe tell you the truth.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | FeedLetter | Substack polls | Substack surveys |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lives in | Links in your post | Inside your post | Its own page |
| Price | Free plan with 25 surveys, then paid | Free | Free |
| Made for every issue | Yes | No | No |
| Comments after the vote | Yes | No | Yes, as survey questions |
| Voice messages from readers | Yes | No | No |
| Readers see the results | No | Yes | No |
| Answer without subscribing | Yes | - | No |
| Works on other email platforms | Yes | No | No |
| Works on websites and in ebooks | Yes | No | No |
| Report per issue over time | Yes | No | No |
| Wall of Love | Yes | No | No |
Some of the FeedLetter features, like voice messages and exports, are part of the Professional and Business plans. See the pricing.
You don’t have an email platform yet?
Then choose the platform first and the feedback tool second. If you don’t need the network of Substack and would rather own your list and your brand, take a look at EmailOctopus and Buttondown. Both are simple, fair and do one thing well: sending your newsletter. FeedLetter works with both, and for EmailOctopus it even fetches your sending stats.
What You Should Do Now
Happy with Substack polls, and Substack is the only place where you need feedback? Stay with them.
Do you want to know with every issue what your readers think and why? Then try the newsletter survey of FeedLetter. It works on Substack, and the free plan covers 25 surveys, which is about six months of a weekly newsletter.