FeedLetter VS a Self-Made Google Form - Which Should You Use?
Google Forms is free, you probably have a Google account already, and a feedback form is built in ten minutes. So why would anyone pay for a feedback tool?
Fair question. I built FeedLetter, so I am biased. But I used forms for my own newsletters before, and that is the reason FeedLetter exists.
First, a quick decision guide for you.
If you want to ask many questions once or twice a year …
… then use Google Forms.
For the big reader survey, a form is the right tool. Who are your readers, what do they do, what do they struggle with, what would they pay for? You need several questions and different question types for that, and Google Forms does it well. The answers land in a spreadsheet, and it doesn’t cost a thing.
FeedLetter can’t do that. It asks one question at a time.
If you want feedback on every issue …
… then pick FeedLetter.
Here the form fails, and not because of Google. It fails because it is a form.
People don’t like forms and surveys. A link to a form at the end of your email means: open a page, read the questions, think, type, submit. Most readers won’t even start. In my experience, only a small number of your most engaged readers fill it out, and even they stop when you ask too often.
FeedLetter removes that friction with a 2-step process. Step one is a click on a link in your email, and the vote is already counted. Step two is a comment page where the reader can tell you why, by text or with a voice message. No form, no login, one tiny step at a time.
One of my users put it like this:
The feedback in my most recent newsletter was more than the combined feedback of all my previous issues using Google Forms.
What you have to build yourself with a form
A self-made form gives you a list of answers. The rest is your job:
- One form per issue, or one for all? With one form for all issues, you don’t know which issue an answer belongs to. With one form per issue, you copy forms and spreadsheets every week.
- Results over time. To see which issues and topics work, you build your own spreadsheet and keep it up to date.
- One-click voting. You can prefill a form with a link, but the reader still has to submit it.
- A page for the reader after the answer, with your own text and a button to your archive or product.
FeedLetter does this for you. Every issue gets its own survey and its own report, and you see how your issues perform over time.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | FeedLetter | Google Forms |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free plan with 25 surveys, then paid | Free |
| Many questions and question types | No | Yes |
| One-click voting from the email | Yes | No |
| Comments | Yes | Yes |
| Voice messages from readers | Yes | No |
| Report per issue over time | Yes | No, build your own spreadsheet |
| Feedback widget for your website | Yes | No, link or embedded form |
| Custom thank-you page with button | Yes | Confirmation message only |
| Wall of Love | Yes | No |
Some of the FeedLetter features, like voice messages and custom thank-you pages, are part of the Professional and Business plans. See the pricing.
What You Should Do Now
Use both, each for what it does best.
Send a short Google Form once or twice a year to learn who your readers are. And add a newsletter survey of FeedLetter to every issue to learn what they think of it. The free plan covers 25 surveys, which is about six months of a weekly newsletter.
More ways to ask your readers are in How to Get Feedback for Your Newsletter.