FeedLetter VS Vibe-Coding Your Own Feedback Tool
“Three links and a comment box? I can vibe-code that in a weekend.”
Yes, you can. With an AI coding tool, a first version is running in an evening. I am a developer myself, and I won’t tell you it is impossible.
I’ll do the opposite. Here is the prompt to get you started, and an honest list of what comes after it. Then you decide.
The prompt
Copy it, it’s free:
Build a feedback tool for my newsletter.
- I create one survey per newsletter issue. Each survey has three
answers: liked it, it was okay, didn't like it.
- For each survey, give me three links I can paste into any email
platform. A click on a link counts as a vote.
- After the click, show the reader a page where they can leave an
optional comment, name and email. Then show a thank-you page.
- Readers stay anonymous. No login, no cookies for tracking.
- Count only one vote per reader and survey, without knowing who
the reader is.
- Don't count clicks from link scanners, spam filters and bots.
Mail servers open every link in an email before the reader sees it.
- Protect the comment form against spam.
- Give me an admin area with a login, a report per issue and a
chart of how my issues perform over time.
- Let me export votes and comments as CSV.
- Delete IP addresses after 30 days. Write a privacy policy that
matches what the tool really does.
- Deploy it with HTTPS on my own domain, with daily backups and
monitoring that tells me when it's down.
The first four points are the weekend. The rest is where the time goes.
What the first version will miss
Bots vote before your readers do. This one gets everybody, and it got me too. Spam filters, virus checkers and corporate mail servers follow every link in an email before it reaches the inbox. For a tool where a click is a vote, that means votes from machines. In the early days of FeedLetter, some “readers” clicked all my voting links in every single email. It turned out to be a server that checked the links before delivering the email.
There is no clean fix for it. FeedLetter blocks the known IP ranges of the big clouds and of mail protection servers, and I’ve been updating that list since 2022. Your version starts from zero, and you only notice the problem when your numbers look too good.
Double votes without tracking. Counting one vote per reader is easy when you know who the reader is. Doing it while the reader stays anonymous is not.
Somebody has to run it. A server, updates, backups, a certificate that renews, a database that fills up. And spam bots that find your comment form in week three.
Privacy is your job now. You store IP addresses and comments of your readers. You need to know what you store, for how long and why, and write it down.
The time comparison
These are my estimates for someone who can read code. If you can’t, double them.
| Task | Vibe-coded | FeedLetter |
|---|---|---|
| First working version | 1 evening to 1 weekend | 5 minutes to sign up and create a survey |
| Hosting, domain, HTTPS, backups | 1 day | 0 |
| Bot and scanner filtering | 2 to 3 days, and never finished | 0 |
| Double vote protection, spam protection | 1 to 2 days | 0 |
| Reports, issues over time, export | 2 to 3 days | 0 |
| Privacy policy and data clean-up | 1 day | 0 |
| Maintenance | A few hours every month | 0 |
| A new survey for each issue | Depends on what you built | Under a minute |
That is one to two weeks of work until you can trust the numbers, plus a server to pay for and a tool that depends on you.
The Professional plan of FeedLetter is $156 per year. What is an hour of your time worth?
Build it yourself when …
… you enjoy building things and want to learn how they work. That is a good reason, and I mean it.
… feedback is the core of your product, and you need something no tool gives you.
… you already run your own servers and one more service doesn’t matter.
Pick FeedLetter when …
… you want to write your newsletter, not maintain a tool.
… you need numbers you can trust from the first issue.
… you want more than the three links: voice messages, one-time polls, a feedback widget for your website and a Wall of Love.
FeedLetter has been running for more than five years and still gets regular updates. All the mistakes in the list above are already made and fixed.
What You Should Do Now
If the prompt above made you smile and you can’t wait to open your editor, go build it. Have fun, and watch out for the bots.
If it made you tired, try the newsletter survey of FeedLetter. The free plan covers 25 surveys with unlimited votes, and there is an API if you still want to build something on top.