Comparison

beehiiv Polls VS FeedLetter - Which Should You Use?

beehiiv has polls built in, and FeedLetter is a feedback tool that works with links. Both let your readers answer with one click. So which one should you use?

I built FeedLetter, so I am biased. But I’d rather tell you when you don’t need it than have you sign up for the wrong reasons. The facts about beehiiv are from its help pages, as of November 2026.

First, a quick decision guide for you.

If you already use beehiiv polls and are happy …

… then keep using them. Seriously.

If you are on a paid beehiiv plan, only want feedback inside your newsletter and the polls do the job for you, there is no reason to add another tool. beehiiv polls are well made. You can show the results to your readers, redirect them after the vote, collect additional feedback, export the results as a CSV file and even build segments from the answers.

If you want feedback in other places too …

… then pick FeedLetter.

beehiiv polls live in your beehiiv posts. But your readers are in more places than your newsletter. FeedLetter works anywhere you can place a link or a snippet: in after-sales emails and onboarding sequences, in ebooks, in online courses and with a feedback widget on your website.

All your feedback ends up in one place, no matter where it came from.

If you care about vendor independence or privacy …

… then pick FeedLetter too.

Your poll results live in beehiiv. When you move your newsletter to another platform one day, your surveys don’t move with you. FeedLetter is just links, so it works the same on every email platform, and your results and the history of your issues stay with you.

The other point is privacy. beehiiv ties each answer to the subscriber. You find a subscriber’s poll answers in their subscriber profile. That is useful for segments, but your readers are not anonymous.

FeedLetter doesn’t link votes to readers. They stay anonymous and add their name or email only if they want to. And readers who feel safe tell you the truth.

Feature Comparison

FeatureFeedLetterbeehiiv polls
One-click voting in emailsYesYes
Available on a free planYes, 25 surveysNo, paid plans and the free trial
Works on every email platformYesNo, beehiiv only
Works on websites, in ebooks and other emailsYesNo
Comments after the voteYesYes, with “Collect additional feedback”
Voice messages from readersYesNo
Anonymous votesYesNo, answers are tied to the subscriber
Segments based on answersNoYes
Trivia pollsNoYes
Show results to readersNoYes
Export resultsYesYes
Report per issue over timeYesResults per post and a polls dashboard
Wall of LoveYesNo

Some of the FeedLetter features, like voice messages and exports, are part of the Professional and Business plans. See the pricing.

You don’t have an email platform yet?

Then choose the platform first and the feedback tool second. If you don’t need everything beehiiv offers, take a look at EmailOctopus and Buttondown. Both are simple, fair and do one thing well: sending your newsletter. FeedLetter works with both, and for EmailOctopus it even fetches your sending stats.

What You Should Do Now

Happy with beehiiv polls, and the newsletter is the only place where you need feedback? Stay with them.

Do you want honest, anonymous feedback, in your newsletter and everywhere else your readers are? Then try the newsletter survey of FeedLetter. The free plan covers 25 surveys, which is about six months of a weekly newsletter.