Comparison

Kit Polls VS FeedLetter - Which Should You Use?

Kit, formerly ConvertKit, added polls to its emails in 2024. FeedLetter has been collecting newsletter feedback with simple links for more than five years. Both let your readers answer with one click. So which one should you use?

I built FeedLetter, so I am biased. But I’d rather tell you when you don’t need it. The facts about Kit are from its help pages, as of November 2026.

First, a quick decision guide for you.

If you already use Kit polls and are happy …

… then keep using them.

If you are on a paid Kit plan, only want feedback inside your newsletter and a quick vote is enough for you, there is no reason to add another tool. Kit polls take up to six options, work in broadcasts and sequences, can show the results after the vote and can add a tag to everyone who clicked an option. That is great for segmenting your list.

If you want feedback in other places too …

… then pick FeedLetter.

Kit polls work in Kit emails and in the broadcasts you publish to the web, and only your subscribers can answer. FeedLetter works anywhere you can place a link or a snippet: in after-sales emails, in ebooks, in online courses and with a feedback widget on your website. Anyone with the link can answer.

If you want to know why readers voted …

… then pick FeedLetter.

A Kit poll gives you votes. After the click, the reader sees a confirmation message, and that’s it.

In FeedLetter, the vote is only step one. In step two, the reader lands on a comment page and can tell you why, by text or with a voice message. This 2-step process is where the GOLDMINE is. A vote tells you that readers didn’t like an issue. The comments tell you what to change.

If you care about vendor independence or privacy …

… then pick FeedLetter too.

Your poll results live in the analytics of your Kit broadcasts and sequences. When you switch platforms one day, they stay behind. FeedLetter is just links, so it works the same on every email platform, and the history of your issues stays with you.

On privacy, Kit does it better than most. The results don’t list who voted for which option. But as soon as you add tags to the options, you know it anyway. In FeedLetter, readers stay anonymous and add their name or email only if they want to.

Feature Comparison

FeatureFeedLetterKit polls
One-click voting in emailsYesYes
Available on a free planYes, 25 surveysNo, paid plans only
Number of options3 per newsletter survey, 1 to 5 per one-time pollUp to 6
Works on every email platformYesNo, Kit only
Works on websites, in ebooks and other emailsYesNo
Comments after the voteYesNo
Voice messages from readersYesNo
Anonymous votesYesYes, unless you tag the options
Tag subscribers by answerNoYes
Show results to readersNoYes
Report per issue over timeYesResults in each broadcast’s analytics
Wall of LoveYesNo

Some of the FeedLetter features, like voice messages and exports, are part of the Professional and Business plans. See the pricing.

You don’t have an email platform yet?

Then choose the platform first and the feedback tool second. If you don’t need the automations of Kit, take a look at EmailOctopus and Buttondown. Both are simple, fair and do one thing well: sending your newsletter. FeedLetter works with both, and for EmailOctopus it even fetches your sending stats.

What You Should Do Now

Happy with Kit polls, and a quick vote in your newsletter is all you need? Stay with them.

Do you want to know why your readers voted the way they did, in your newsletter and everywhere else? Then try the newsletter survey of FeedLetter. It works in Kit on every plan, also on the free one, because it’s just links.